Small Tile vs. Large Tile: Which Costs Less for DIYers?
Small Tile vs. Large Tile: Which Costs Less for DIYers?
We have all been there. You are standing in a discount tile showroom (or scrolling late in Pinterest, swimming between all the ideas), staring at two very different samples. On one hand, you have an authentic and boho inspired sheet of mosaic tile. In the other, a sleek and suited up, massive slab of large format porcelain tile. And we know, your heart says, “Go big or go home,” but on the other hand, our wallet is whispering, “Please don’t make us eat noodles for a month.”
When you try to do a big renovation in your own home, by yourself, the price tag on the box is only half the story. The real cost hides in the details you couldn’t count on. The grout, the waste, the tools, and the really good amount of sweat equity you are willing to pour in. So, let’s settle the debate of small tile vs large tile. Which one actually saves you money when you are the one holding the trowel?
Let’s Start with Budget: What Are You Actually Paying For?
At first glance, larger tiles often seem like a bargain, an opportunity you can’t miss right now. If you look at a standard 12×24 tile or a 24×24 tile, the cost per square foot is often surprisingly low, especially in the discount tile collections. Mass production makes these sizes affordable.
On the flip side of the coin, a mosaic tile or a trendy small hexagon tile often commands a higher price per square foot. Why? Because there is more manufacturing involved. More cuts, more mesh backing, more packaging. So, if you want one of them to win the first, purely on material cost? Large format tile usually takes the gold. But wait, don’t swipe that credit card yet. The installation is where things start to change!
The Unexpected Costs of Going Big
If you choose a large format marble tile, as an example, your subfloor needs to be flatter than a pancake. If your floor has a dip (and let’s be real, most floors do), a large tile will bridge that gap and eventually crack, or create lippage, that annoying toe, stubbing edge where one tile is higher than the other.
To fix this, you need self leveling underlayment (that’ll be expensive) and a specialized tile leveling system with clips and wedges (oops, an added cost). Plus, cutting a thick 24×24 tile usually requires a wet saw. You can’t just snap these unexpected guests with a cheap manual cutter. You’ll likely need to rent a pro grade saw, and that’s the cost we don’t want. See? Suddenly, that cheap large tile is racking up a serious bill in tools and prep materials.
It’s Never One Faced: The Unexpected Costs of Going Small
So, is small tile vs large tile a clear win for the little guys? Not exactly. Small tiles, like a 4×4 backsplash tile or a subway backsplash tile, are generally easier to cut. You can often use a simple snap cutter or even a pair of nippers for mesh mounted mosaics. The physical labor of lugging them around is easier, too. However, the cost here comes in the form of grout. A LOT of grout, especially if you’re trying to get a good design that doesn’t look like an intern job.
If you are installing a small hexagon tile, you have thousands of grout lines. That means buying more bags of grout and spending hours (and hours) floating, sponging, and hazing. If you are hiring help, this drives the labor cost up. If you are DIYing, it costs you your weekend me time.
The Shower Situation: A Specific Warning
This is where the debate of large tile vs small tile in shower environments gets technical. For a shower floor, you need a slope towards the drain. Trying to force a stiff, flat, large format tile to conform to a curved slope is a geometry nightmare. You end up having to make envelope cuts, which look messy if not done perfectly.
This is why mosaic tile or a small hexagon tile is one of the best choices for shower floors, the many grout lines allow the sheet to flex and hug the slope. It’s safer (a really good non slip shower floor option) and significantly easier for a DIYer to install without water pooling issues.
Let’s Point Out Aesthetics
Small Spaces: You wouldn’t guess it, but hear us out: Paradoxically, a large hexagon tile or 12×24 tile can make a tiny powder room feel huge because there are fewer visual breaks (grout lines).
Backsplash Tiles: Here is the place where we stick with the classics. A subway backsplash tile is the ultimate DIY friend. It’s cheap, forgiving, and timeless, no matter which color they are. If you are confused about the endless sizing options, we actually wrote a whole guide on Subway Tile Sizes to help you navigate that specific maze.
Let’s End the Trial: Who is the DIY Cost Winner?
The Winner for Beginners: Choosing the easier option is kind of a grace. Go with a medium size tile, like a standard 12×24 tile or subway tile sizes. Why? They are exactly what you are looking for. They are big enough that you aren’t drowning in grout, but small enough that they are manageable to cut and forgive a slightly uneven wall.
The Winner for Advanced DIYers: If you have the tools (or a rental connection) and a flat subfloor, large format tile is technically cheaper per square foot and offers a high end, seamless look that increases property value. Keep that in mind.
Take A Small Step or Big: We Have Both!
At Stone Tile Depot, we specialize in both small tiles like mosaic tiles, and large format tiles. And everything in between at prices that let you afford the good grout work. Don’t let the large tile vs small tile debate paralyze you, we’ll be fine. Measure your space, check your subfloor, and pick the one that makes your heart beat a little faster. Then, you know what to do: order a tile sample or call our clearance tile showroom to get more details!
See All Mosaic Tiles